GBA Logo horizontal Facebook LinkedIn Email Pinterest Twitter Instagram YouTube Icon Navigation Search Icon Main Search Icon Video Play Icon Plus Icon Minus Icon Picture icon Hamburger Icon Close Icon Sorted

Community and Q&A

Foam under footings for a trellis

Scorched Earth, 3B| Posted inGeneral Questionson

I can’t remember which Q&A post or blog post gave a rule of thumb for foam thickness and below-grade depth equivalents–might have been here somewhere (below) but I’m not sure.

//m.etiketa4.com/blogs/dept/musings/foam-under-footings

I’m in Minneapolis and I get a lot of heat gain through the windows on the west side of my house, so I’m putting my trellis plans together to bring into plan review. Footers need to be 42″ deep to go below the frost line. I’ve already got some 1/2″ EPS sitting around and will have some 2″ scrap pieces soon enough. I’d love to be able to pour my five footings for these posts to, say, 12″ deep each over foam instead of 42″+ each.

Is there someplace in the IRC I can refer to, to have some chance of successfully proposing shallower footings that will still be frost-protected?

GBA Prime

Join the leading community of building science experts

Become a GBA Prime member and get instant access to the latest developments in green building, research, and reports from the field.

Replies

  1. Devin Ratliff||#1

    Minn D,

    It sounds like you're talking about a frost-protected shallow foundation. The IRC recognizes this type of foundation, and has criteria about how thick the foam has to be and how far it has to extend from the foundation wall, but it does not sound like it is at all applicable for what you are describing. An FPSF relies on a continuously heated structure (not allowed for unheated structures) to raise the frost level adjeacent to the building, so that you don't have to dig as deep. But it sounds like what you're describing is a secondary structure outside of your buidling's foundation. Just putting down foam doesn't lower the frost depth, which is the reason for the 42". Maybe if you skirted our from your building foundation beyond your new foundations - but it's a big stretch.

    I think you're going to need that posthole digger.

  2. GBA Editor
    Martin Holladay||#2

    Drat,
    You're wrong when you write, "An FPSF relies on a continuously heated structure (not allowed for unheated structures) to raise the frost level adjacent to the building."

    For more information on these foundations, see my article in Fine Homebuilding:
    http://www.finehomebuilding.com/design/departments/energy-smart-details/frost-protected-shallow-foundations.aspx?ac=fp

    In that article, I noted, "Fortunately, these shallow foundations don’t depend on leaking building heat to keep the soil warm. Instead, horizontal wing insulation extending from the bottom edge of the slab helps to retain the natural warmth of the earth."

    Also, see this document:Revised Builder’s Guide to Frost Protected Shallow Foundations.
    Design details for unheated buildings begin on page 17 of that document.

  3. Scorched Earth, 3B||#3

    Thank you. The Revised FPSF Guide is the document I was thinking of.

    So, with an incomplete understanding of the issue, I am asking if it's true that I may indeed set an inch of EPS under my footers for this trellis/pergola/whatever, and dig them to a depth of only 16"+ if I'm in a 3,000 HDD location. Page 28:

    "Finally, because of the insulation, the frost line will not penetrate as deeply into the soil around the foundation."

  4. Scorched Earth, 3B||#4

    By the way, the first 12" or so down are the toughest anyway, so it's not going to kill me either way. But I'd like to know.

  5. Devin Ratliff||#5

    Thanks for the clarification and links Martin; I stand corrected (once again, I wish that I'd found GBA sooner!)

    In this case though, I think the answer goes from 'not allowed' to 'not practical'. Check out those horizontal insulation values for unheated structures in the buider's guide: with an air freezing index of 2000-3000, you're looking at an unmodified 63-79" of horizontal insulation! Unless you can harness the heat of your house (and even if you can, you're looking at 24" horizontal as a corner condition), it sounds way easier to dig down to frost.

    Minneapolis, I think what you're suggesting is simply laying a board of insulation under your post foundation, which won't work. An FPSF relies on a skirt of horizontal insulation around the structure - either to retain the building's heat (less of a skirt required because there's more heat there) or the earth's heat (more of a skirt required because there's less heat there). If the first 12" of digging is the hardest, then an SPSF (shallow but wide) is going to be a lot more work than going down to frost (narrow, but deep).

  6. J Chesnut||#6

    Minne D,

    I am asking if it's true that I may indeed set an inch of EPS under my footers for this trellis/pergola/whatever, and dig them to a depth of only 16"+ if I'm in a 3,000 HDD location.

    Minneapolis is a 8000 HDD climate not 3000.
    Maybe it was a typo in post #3, if not it might change your depth determination.

  7. Scorched Earth, 3B||#7

    Haha, thanks. In any case if I go to 42" uninsulated, I'm set.

Log in or create an account to post an answer.

Community

Recent Questions and Replies

  • |
  • |
  • |
  • |