Under-slab insulation: XPS or EPS?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/956a8/956a8c6cf58d98196dcbe0124f6d8fd8e00a3690" alt=""
We’re building a slab-on-grade home with radiant floor hydronics in the floor, and are wondering what type of rigid-foam insulation is best for under-slab insulation. (We’re planning on 3″ inches of insulation, no matter what product we use.)
GBA Detail Library
A collection of one thousand construction details organized by climate and house part
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f4641/f464130c2d3236e6e9e93630a698a70ac84b0d56" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/91125/91125a993db3b6af67491079bd3fc16059d08d29" alt=""
Replies
Both XPS and EPS have been used successfully below grade, but XPS is still the standard because it typically has more compressive strength and higher R-value per inch.
Your thermal design program should specify a certain required R-value for sub-slab insulation rather than a certain thickness. 3" of EPS would offer no more than R-12, while the same thickness of XPS would give you R-15 (a 25% increase).
Where are you building and what is the heating Degree-Day total for your climate zone? In a cold climate (>7200 HDD) and for a highly-insulated house, R-20 to R-30 subslab insulation is commonly recommended for radiant slabs. Be sure to insulate the slab edges at least to the level of the sub-slab insulation, as most heat is lost from a slab at the edges to the ambient air temperature.
Hi Robert ~
We're building in southernmost Oregon (Medford area), with a HDD total of 4,566. Code calls for R-10 under-slab insulation, but we'd like to boost it to R-15, since we're relying on radiant floor and passive solar heating.
I did find a good PDF on slab insulation details at buildingscience.com. Do you have any other sites to recommend?
Thanks,
Claire
我想你已经看到了俄勒冈州的住宅Energy Code brochure on slab insulation:http://www.oregon.gov/ENERGY/CONS/Codes/docs/ResPub_9.pdf.
They require R-15 slab edge insulation for all heated spaces. The slab edge insulation value can be the combined R-value of perimeter insulation and slab-edge, if it's not a monolithic pour. But since the majority of heat loss is from the edge, if you're increasing subslab insulation to R-15, you might consider increasing slab-edge insulation to R-20.