Radiant barrier roof for a Passive House?
yavaid| Posted inPassivHauson
Hi,
Is it worth using Radiant Barrier under the roof in Passive House (both vented/unvented) Roof ?
Thanks
Naveen
GBA Detail Library
A collection of one thousand construction details organized by climate and house part
Search and download construction details
Replies
There is no place to even put the radiant barrier where it has any effect whatsoever in an unvented roof unless exposed directly to the room. Are you OK with a shiny metallic ceiling?
In a vented roof it will have a modest effect on energy usage, but whether it increases or decreases energy use would have to be modeled for the local climate, site factors, and house design. Whether it's "worth using" depends on how it models, and what your design goals are. In a Passive House one might also ask if it is "worth using" a foot of EPS under slab. It might be if that's final bit that it takes to meet the energy use requirements for Passive House certification, but going that thick makes no sense on a "net present value of future energy cost savings" basis.
Hi Naveen -
Research done by the Dept of Energy some years ago revealed little to no benefit from radiant barriers in roof assemblies (attics) in all but the hottest climates (pretty sure benefit restricted to CZ 1- 3).
Peter
PS - in order for any radiant barrier to work, it must face an open space.
>"Research done by the Dept of Energy some years ago revealed little to no benefit from radiant barriers in roof assemblies (attics) in all but the hottest climates (pretty sure benefit restricted to CZ 1- 3)."
It's worse than just not having a benefit.
Research at the national laboratories indicates that radiant barriers can even increase energy use (a negative benefit) when applied in colder climates by reducing beneficial solar gains that would offset heating energy use.
Thanks Dana and Peter, I am in Zone4a and was going for vented roof. Design will go through PHPP in couple of days. I have posed this with PH Consultant who pretty much cited what you have suggested.
Thanks,
Naveen
Naveen,
For a thorough discussion of this topic, see"Radiant Barriers: A Solution in Search of a Problem."