答复

1. 
   内森豆|2018年3月13日09:00 PM|＃1

   杰米，

   传热板依靠传导带warmth to the floor, while suspended tubes rely on convection and radiation through the air space. This is less efficient at transferring heat, and will require hotter supply water - in the neighborhood of 160 to 200 degrees F.

   Both staple-up and suspended tubes traditionally use an air gap (with insulation and a radiant barrier installed below), so the discussion from the building science paper you mention applies to both.

   You also need to support the tubing every 24 to 30 inches, which involves additional labor and material costs.

   John Siegenthaler是“现代水性加热：为住宅和轻型商业建筑”的最佳信息之一。您可以选择使用不到20美元。

2. 
   卡尔森|Mar 13, 2018 09:02pm|＃2

   我不了解效率，但最后一个辐射的房子我确实是主地装上的管道，地下室是常规嵌入式戳。在HVAC伙计们之前推动了平板，使我使用的是。我对文件的持怀疑态度，似乎是穷人的辐射，但房主爱地板，说票据并没有出于普通，如果这些人爱他们，它一定是好的导致纹理鼻屎和这位女士会抱怨。它就像一把橡皮软管，他们用宽阔的皇冠钉枪钉起来。

3. 
   Richard McGrath|2018年3月13日09:53 PM|＃3

   挤出的铝传热板不需要，也不应该有空体。将管道发射的所有热量应集中在板上并通过传导进入地板。传导是国王。

   Higher temp water will lower your boiler efficiencies also . The colder the return water , the higher your efficiencies go . Insulation below should be a minimum of R19 and should be installed tight to the bottom of the sub floor .

   If cost is an issue and high temps and efficiencies lower than 90% do not bother you , you should probably consider economical radiant ceiling design which uses higher temp ( 169*) and a very small portion of the ceiling as the emitter , that portion is on the perimeter and is about 10 - 20 % of the available ceiling , also done with extruded aluminum plates fastened to the bottom of beams or rafters and 1" strapping or 3/4" running parallel with the plates and tubes , R 13 would be sufficient above . If you chose to go with 60 - 70% of the ceiling it would be less expense than floors , lower water temps that are reasonably conducive to very good boiler efficiency and floors , walls would stay within 1-2 * of room setpoint temp .

   Ceilings are actually more comfortable than floors . Not new technology , on the contrary , just a lost art that served many well for decades . until the available labor pool no longer knew how it worked . Don't ask if heat rises , what do we think the odds are that the top of the sun is always facing Earth or maybe it turns over in the winter twice a day .

   夹心也在欧博尔的CDAM和Siggy的MHH3中，如前所述。您还将在Robert Beans健康的加热网站上找到对它们的参考，我在房屋中完成了几十次成功的天花板工作，从1,500到10,000平方英尺。所有最终用户都爱上了他们。

4. 专家成员
   达娜·迪斯特|2018年3月14日08:16 AM|＃4

   BSC文章是关于未被用作散热器的未加热地板。辐射改变一切。

   出于相同的热量速度，悬挂管需要最高的水温，然后是简单的叠钉（无散热器），然后悬挂管与翅片式热交换器，然后是钣金散热器，具有最低的挤压铝散热器。（一些更好的钣金类型比最窄的挤出式散热器更好。）只有悬浮管变体需要任何类型的气隙，允许对流环操作在腔内。